Separating from a partner involves many complex financial considerations, especially when it comes to property division. One of the most contentious issues can be determining how gifts and inheritances should be treated. Whether you received an inheritance before your relationship began or a significant gift during your marriage, these assets often hold both financial and emotional value. If you need help with property division in Brisbane, understanding how Australian family law approaches these matters is essential.
Key Takeaways
- Gifts and inheritances can be included in the property pool depending on timing, use, and mixing with other assets
- Courts consider both when the gift/inheritance was received and how it contributed to the relationship
- Keeping inheritances separate and documented improves chances of retaining them after separation
- Binding Financial Agreements can help protect significant gifts or expected inheritances
- Early legal advice is critical to understanding your specific situation
Legal Principles Governing Gifts and Inheritances
The Family Law Act 1975 provides the framework for how property is divided after a relationship breakdown. When it comes to gifts and inheritances, they aren’t automatically excluded from the property pool simply because they came from a third party.
For an asset to be considered ‘property’ under the Act, it must be owned by either party or under their control. This includes money, real estate, shares, and interests in trusts. The timing of when a gift or inheritance was received plays a significant role in how it’s treated – those received well before a relationship may be treated differently from those received shortly before separation.
The distinction between separate property and relationship property isn’t black and white in Australian law. Unlike some jurisdictions, Australia doesn’t automatically ring-fence inherited assets or gifts.
When Gifts and Inheritances Enter the Property Pool
Several factors determine whether a gift or inheritance becomes part of the divisible asset pool:
- Timing of receipt (before, during or after the relationship)
- How the gift or inheritance was used (personal vs family benefit)
- ‘Mixing’ with other assets (keeping separate vs combining with joint property)
- Length of the relationship after the gift was received
- Donor’s stated intention (intended for one party vs the family unit)
Gifts clearly made to just one partner are more likely to remain with that person, particularly if they’ve been kept separate. However, if an inheritance was used to renovate the family home or pay down a joint mortgage, it becomes much harder to extract its value later.
“We often see clients who mistakenly believe their inheritance is automatically protected. The reality is that once those funds are used for family purposes, they typically become part of the shared asset pool.” – Stewart Family Law
Valuation and Apportionment by Courts
When a court examines gifts and inheritances, they don’t just look at current value but also at how that value was maintained or increased during the relationship. Expert valuations may be required for assets like businesses or real estate that were purchased or improved using gifted funds.
Tracing the flow of money is often critical in these cases. Courts examine bank statements, transfer records, and correspondence to determine how funds were used. This paper trail can make the difference in how an inheritance is ultimately treated.
The court has broad discretion to make adjustments based on factors beyond financial contributions, including future needs, care of children, and each party’s earning capacity. Even a clearly traced inheritance might be partially shared if one party has significantly greater needs.
Protecting Gifts and Inheritances
If you want to protect a gift or inheritance, consider these practical steps:
Keep funds separate: Maintain inherited assets in accounts under your sole name and avoid using them for joint expenses if possible.
Document intentions: If a family member intends a gift for you specifically, ask them to document this intention.
Binding Financial Agreements: These are Australian prenuptial or postnuptial agreements that can specifically address how gifts and inheritances should be treated if the relationship ends.
Trust structures: Family trusts and testamentary trusts can provide some protection, though they aren’t bulletproof in family law proceedings.
Evidence to Support Your Claim
If you’re hoping to retain an inheritance or gift after separation, collecting proper documentation is vital:
For inheritances: copies of the will, probate documents, correspondence showing the testator’s intention, and evidence of how the inheritance was managed.
For gifts: letters or emails from the donor stating their intention, bank transfer records, and documentation showing how the gift was used or maintained.
Financial records: bank statements showing the separate handling of funds can significantly strengthen your position.
Common Scenarios
Inheritance received before the relationship: More likely to be treated as a special contribution by that party, especially if it was substantial and kept separate.
Inheritance received during the relationship: Often considered a contribution by the receiving party, but the longer the relationship continued afterward, the more likely some sharing will occur.
Gift used for joint property: When a gift is used for a deposit on a family home or to start a family business, courts typically view this as a contribution to joint assets, though not necessarily an equal one.
Dispute Resolution Options
Most property settlements are resolved without court intervention. Mediation offers a cost-effective way to negotiate fair treatment of gifts and inheritances.
If court proceedings are necessary, be prepared for a process that typically takes 12-18 months and involves significant expense. This timeline often motivates parties to reach reasonable settlements.
When negotiating, understand that Australian family law focuses on achieving fair outcomes rather than mathematical precision. This means being realistic about what portion of an inheritance might reasonably be retained.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a gift always be shared in a property settlement?
No. Gifts aren’t automatically shared, especially if they were received recently, kept separate, or clearly intended for one party alone.
Can an inheritance be protected from division?
While no absolute protection exists, keeping inheritances separate and documented improves your chances of retaining them.
What happens if gifted funds were mixed in joint accounts?
Mixing funds (called ‘intermingling’) often results in the gift becoming part of the joint asset pool, making it difficult to extract later.
Next Steps in Your Property Settlement
Dealing with gifts and inheritances during property settlement requires careful consideration of timing, use, and documentation. While general principles exist, each case is unique and depends on your specific circumstances.
If you’re facing separation and have concerns about inherited assets or gifts, gathering documentation early is crucial. Stewart Family Law can provide specialised advice tailored to your situation and help you understand the likely treatment of these assets under Australian law. Taking proactive steps early can significantly improve your position in negotiations or court proceedings.
Add Comment